Academic All-American (includes all-district selections)
| Year | Player |
| 1952 | Bill Fenton |
1953Bill FentonJerry Hilgenberg1975Bob Elliott1984Larry Station1985Larry Station1987Chuck Hartlieb1997Matt Reischl1998Matt Reischl1999Aaron KampmanThad SheldonRob Thein2000Aaron KampmanAndrew Lightfoot2001Aaron KampmanAndrew Lightfoot2002Jared ClaussNate KaedingAndrew Lightfoot2003Jared ClaussNate Kaeding2004Kody AsmusSean Considine2005Mike ElginAndy FenstermakerMike KlinkenborgAdam Shada
Academic All Big Ten
| Year | Player |
1953Bill FentonJerry Hilgenberg1954Warren Lawson1955Dick Dessy1956Frank Bloomquist1966Bob GibbsTony Williams1967Tony Williams1968Ray Manning1969Ray ManningSteve PenneyKerry Reardon1970Ray ManningKerry Reardon1971Dave Triplett1974Dave BryantBob ElliottJim HilgenbergBrandt Yocum1975Dennis ArmingtonBob ElliottJim HilgenbergNick QuartaroBrandt Yocum1976Rod Sears1978Greg GilbaughTim GutshallMario Pace1980Dave MayhanBrad Webb1981Dave MayhanBrad Webb1983Dave Chambers1984Bill HappelLarry Station1985Mike FlaggBill HappelRob HoughtlinLarry Station1986Dave CrostonMike FlaggJ.J. PukMark Vlasic1987Marv CookMike FlaggChuck HartliebJ.J. PukHerb Wester1988Mike ErtzGreg FeddersChuck Hartlieb1989Mike Ertz1990Mike DaileyTeddy Jo FaleyJim HartliebMike MartensJason OlejniczakMatt Whitaker1991Mike DaileyTeddy Jo FaleyJim HartliebMike MartensJason OlejniczakMatt Whitaker1992Jim HartliebJason OlejniczakMatt Whitaker1993Jeff AndrewsMatt EydeJason Olejniczak1994Eric HilgenbergJosh McKillipJeff Westhoff1995Trevor BollersMichael BurgerAaron GranquistKory HauserEric HilgenbergMatt HughesAron KleinMatt ReischlTodd RomanoDerek RoseTed SeramaJeff WesthoffJohn WilderChris Zdzienicki1996Trevor BollersMichael BurgerBill Ennis-IngeAaron GranquistMatt HughesAron KleinMatt ReischlDerek RoseTed SeramaRob Thein1997Plez AtkinsTrevor BollersMichael BurgerMatt HughesAron KleinMatt ReischlDerek RoseRob Thein1998Jay BickfordMichael BurgerMike DolezalRyan HansenMatt HughesKevin KasperAron KleinKyle McCannRoger MeyerMatt ReischlDerek RoseThad SheldonJoe SlatteryMatt StockdaleRob Thein1999Ryan BartonJay BickfordA.J. BlazekJay DittmanMike DolezalRyan HansenAaron KampmanKevin KasperRoger MeyerThad SheldonJoe SlatteryMatt StockdaleRob Thein2000Ryan BartonA.J. BlazekJared ClaussMike DolezalRyan HansenAaron KampmanKevin KasperAndrew LightfootRoger MeyerBruce NelsonMatt StockdalePete TraynorTony Burrier2001Jeremy AllenTony BurrierJared ClaussSean ConsidineMike DolezalRobert GalleryErik JensenNate KaedingAaron KampmanAndrew LightfootKyle McCannRoger MeyerBruce NelsonMatt Stockdale2002Tony BurrierJared ClaussSean ConsidineAdam DensmoreRobert GalleryErik JensenNate KaedingWill LackAndrew LightfootJohn MickelsonJohn MorscheiserBruce NelsonPete Traynor2003Kody AsmusNathan ChandlerJared ClaussSean ConsidineBrian FerentzRobert GalleryJacob GancarczykErik JensenNate KaedingRyan MajerusMatt MelloyTom Revak2004Kody AsmusC.J. BarkemaSean ConsidineMike ElginMike HumpalRyan MajerusMatt MelloyAlex Willcox2005C.J. BarkemaAndrew BeckerBret ChinanderMike ElginAndy FenstermakerMike HunpalMike KlinkenborgMatt KroulRyan MajerusMatt MelloyDaniel OlsztaCy PhillipsKevin SherlockAdam ShadaNational Football Foundation Scholar-AthleteYearPlayer1968John Charles Hendricks1975Bob Elliott1987Mike Flagg1999Derek Rose