| Nick Allgeyer | 2015-18 | Blue Jays (2021) | July 2, 2021 |
| Boddicker, Mike | 1976-78 | Orioles (1980-88), Red Sox (1988-90), Royals (1991-92), Brewers (1993) | Oct. 4, 1980 |
| Brown, Mace | 1926-29 | Pirates (1935-41), Brooklyn Dodgers (1941), Red Sox (1942-43, 46) | May 21, 1935 |
| Bruner, Jack | 1946-49 | White Sox (1949-50), St. Louis Browns (1950) | Sept. 16, 1949 |
| Costo, Tim | 1988-90 | Reds (1992-93) | Sept. 18, 1992 |
| Cox, Jim | 1969-71 | Expos (1973-76 | July 19, 1973 |
| Dermody, Matt | 2010-13 | Blue Jays (2016-17) | Sept. 3, 2016 |
| Dittmer, Jack | 1947-50 | Boston Braves (1952), Milwaukee Braves (1953-56), Tigers (1957) | June 17, 1952 |
| Eldred, Cal | 1987-89 | Brewers (1991-99), White Sox (2000-01), Cardinals (2003-05) | Sept. 24, 1991 |
| Ford, Gene | 1933-35 | Boston Bees (1936), White Sox (1938) | June 17, 1936 |
| Gebhard, Bob | 1963-65 | Twins (1971-72), Expos (1974) | Aug. 2, 1971 |
| Hatcher, Chris | 1988-90 | Royals (1998) | Sept. 6, 1998 |
| Holm, Wattie | 1922 | Cardinals (1924-29, 1932) | April 15, 1924 |
| Jones, Jeff | 1977-79 | Reds (1983) | April 4, 1983 |
| Kent, Maury | 1904-07 | Brooklyn Dodgers (1912-13) | April 15, 1912 |
| Manders, Hal | 1936-37 | Tigers (1941-42, 1946), Cubs (1946) | Aug. 12, 1941 |
| McAndrew, Jim | 1962-65 | Mets (1968-73), Padres (1974) | July 21, 1968 |
| McIlree, Vance | 1918-20 | Washington Senators (1921) | Sept. 13, 1921 |
| Mowry, Joe | 1928-31 | Boston Braves (1933-35) | May 13, 1933 |
| Mulroney, Frank | 1926-28 | Red Sox (1930) | April 15, 1930 |
| Obermueller, Wes | 1997-99 | Royals (2002), Brewers (2003-05), Marlins (2007) | Sept. 20, 2002 |
| Porter, Bo | 1990-95 | Cubs (1999), Athletics (2000), Rangers (2001) | May 9, 1999 |
| Reinhart, Art | 1918 | Cardinals (1919, 1925-28) | April 26, 1919 |
| Schulte, Len | 1932-34 | St. Louis Browns (1944-46) | Sept. 27, 1944 |
| Sundberg, Jim | 1970-72 | Rangers (1974-83, 1988-89), Brewers (1984), Royals (1985-86, Cubs (1987-88) | April 4, 1974 |
